Developing a Causal Model of Human and Organizational Culture Factors Affecting the Knowledge Management Maturity Using Meta-Synthesis Approach

Document Type: Research Paper


1 Associate Prof., Faculty of Economics, Management and Business, University of Tabriz, Iran

2 MSc. Student in Business Administration, Faculty of Economics, Management and Business, University of Tabriz, Iran


Identifying influential factors which contribute to the knowledge management maturity and studying their interaction over time helps managers to understand the complex behavior of knowledge management system. It also leads them to make right decisions for utilizing these factors in promoting knowledge management and achieve strategic goals of the organization by providing a sound insight and an appropriate mechanism to reach to the optimal maturity level. In this study, all aspects and components of knowledge management with an emphasis on human factors and organizational culture, and relations between them have been identified by using a systematic literature review and meta-synthesis qualitative research approach. Then by using consultation and consensus of experts, all results verified. The results include 64 codes which are classified in 9 dimensions and two categories. Finally, due to the obtained classification and their relations, the dynamic model of knowledge management maturity is presented. The results of this study could be a suitable framework for improving mental models of knowledge management executives and experts. It makes possible Developing dynamic analysis models and appropriate policies in order to improve the knowledge management maturity in organizations.


Main Subjects

Afkhami Rohani, H. & Doaie, H. (2012). Human Resource practices and Implementation of knowledge management relationship in Ferdowsi University of Mashhad. Library And Information Research Journal, 2(1): 55-70. (in persian)

Ajmal, M., Helo, P. & Kekale, T. (2010). Critical factors for knowledge management in project business. Journal of knowledge management, 14(1): 156-168.

Akhavan, P. & Jafari, M. (2006). Critical issues for knowledge management implementation at a national level. VINE, 36(1): 52-66.

Akhavan, P., Hosnavi, R., & Sanjaghi, M. E. (2009). Identification of knowledge management critical success factors in Iranian academic research centers. Education, Business and Society: Contemporary Middle Eastern Issues, 2(4): 276-288.

Alavi, M. & Leidner, D.E. (2001). Review: Knowledge management and knowledge management systems: Conceptual foundations and research issues. MIS quarterly, 25(1): 107-136.

Ashena, M., Asgari, N., Moradi Saleh, A. & ghafoori, D. (2012). The role of organizational culture in facilitating knowledge management practices. Journal of Information Technology Management. 5(4): 1-22. (in Persian)

Awad, E. M., & Ghaziri, H. M. (2004). Knowledge management, 2004. ed: Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey.

Bixler, C. (2002). Knowledge management: a practical solution for emerging global security requirements. Km World, 11(5): 18-28.

Bobbitt, L. (1999). Implementing Knowledge Management Solutions, International Knowledge Management Summit, San Diego, 29–31 March.

Barsky, N. P. & Marchant, G. (2000). The most valuable resource-measuring and managing intellectual capital. Strategic Finance, 81(8): 58-62.

Bassi, L. J. & Van Buren, M. E. (1999). Valuing investments in intellectual capital. International Journal of Technology Management, 18(5-8): 414-432.

Chang, C.L.H. & Lin, T.C. (2015). The role of organizational culture in the knowledge management process. Journal of Knowledge Management, 19(3): 433-455.

Chen, M., Huang, M. & Chen, Y. (2009). Measuring knowledge management performance using a competitive perspective: an empirical study. Expert systems with applications, 36(4): 8449-8459.

Chen, Y. & Huang, H. (2012). Knowledge management fit and its implications for business performance: A profile deviation analysis. Knowledge-Based Systems, 27(9): 262-270.

Choi, B., Poon, S. & Davis, J.G. (2008). Effects of knowledge management strategy on organizational performance: A complementarity theory-based approach. Omega, 36(2): 235-251.

 Collins, C.J. & Clark, K.D. (2003). Strategic human resource practices, top management team social networks, and firm performance: The role of human resource practices in creating organizational competitive advantage. Academy of management Journal, 46(6): 740-751.

Connelly, C. E. & Kevin Kelloway, E. (2003). Predictors of employees' perceptions of knowledge sharing cultures. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 24(5): 294-301.

Chourides, P., Longbottom, D. & Murphy, W. (2003). Excellence in knowledge management: an empirical study to identify critical factors and performance measures. Measuring Business Excellence, 7(2): 29-45.

Darroch, J. (2005). Knowledge management, innovation and firm performance. Journal of Knowledge Management, 9 (3): 101 – 115.

Davenport, T. H. & Prusak, L. (1998). Working knowledge: How organizations manage what they know. Harvard Business Press.

Davenport, T. H. & Klahr, P. (1998). Managing customer support knowledge. California management review, 40(3): 195-208.

Davenport, T. H., De Long, D. W. & Beers, M. C. (1998). Successful knowledge management projects. MIT Sloan Management Review, 39 (2): 43-57.

Davenport, T. H. & Probst, G. J. (2002). Knowledge management case book: Siemens best practices. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Drucker, P. F. (1993). Post capitalist society, Butter worth Heinemann. New York.

Egbu, C.O. (2004). Managing knowledge and intellectual capital for improved organizational innovations in the construction industry: an examination of critical success factors. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 11(5): 301-315.

Ehms, K. & Langen, M. (2002). Holistic development of knowledge management with KMMM. Siemens AG. Retrieved from: /kmmm_article_siemens_2002.pdf.

Finfgeld, D. L. (2003). Metasynthesis: The state of the art -so far. Qualitative health research, 13(7): 893-904.

Fugate, B. S., Stank, T. P. & Mentzer, J. T. (2009). Linking improved knowledge management to operational and organizational performance. Journal of Operations Management, 27(3): 247-264.

Gold, A. H. & Arvind Malhotra, A. H. S. (2001). Knowledge management: An organizational capabilities perspective. Journal of management information systems, 18(1): 185-214.

Hasan Gholipour, T., Abedi Jafari, H. & Khatibian, N. (2009) Measuring Knowledge Management Maturity Level Within Organizations. Using a Developed Maturity Model of Knowledge Management, 4(14): 121-149.
(in persian)

Heisig, P. (2009). Harmonisation of knowledge management-comparing 160 KM frameworks around the globe. Journal of knowledge management, 13(4): 4-31.

Hickins, M. (1999). Xerox shares its knowledge. Management Review, 88(8): 40-45.

Hislop, D. (2003). Linking human resource management and knowledge management via commitment: A review and research agenda. Employee relations, 25(2): 182-202.

Holsapple, C. W. & Joshi, K. D. (2000). An investigation of factors that influence the management of knowledge in organizations. The Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 9(2): 235-261.

Hosseini Azabadi, J. Owlia, M. Noorossana, R. Jafari, M. (2013). Analysis of the effect of knowledge management on organizational excellence through System dynamics approach: a case study on Pars Refractories Company. 11th International Management Conference, Tehran, Iran. (in Persian)

Hsieh, P. J., Lin, B. & Lin, C. (2009). The construction and application of knowledge navigator model (KNM™): An evaluation of knowledge management maturity. Expert Systems with Applications, 36(2): 4087-4100.

Hung, Y. H. & Chou, S. C. T. (2005, August). On constructing a knowledge management pyramid model. In Information Reuse and Integration, Conf, 2005. IRI-2005 IEEE International Conference on. (pp. 1-6). IEEE.

Infosys (2000). KM maturity model. Available in:

Jafari, M. Akhavan, P. Shahanaghi, K. RezaeeNour, J. (2007). Development of dynamic models of knowledge management in knowledge-based organizations. 5th International Industrial Engineering Conference, Tehran, Iran. (in Persian)

Jones, M. C., Cline, M. & Ryan, S. (2006). Exploring knowledge sharing in ERP implementation: an organizational culture framework. Decision Support Systems, 41(2): 411-434.

Jennex, M. E. & Olfman, L. (2004). Assessing knowledge management success/effectiveness models. In System Sciences, 2004. Proceedings of the 37th Annual Hawaii International Conference on (pp. 10-pp). IEEE.

Juniarti, I. & Tasrif, M. (2011). A dynamic view on knowledge development: a case of industrial aerospace supply chain development in indonesia. 2nd Workshop on Systems Modelling for Policy Development.

Kamath, V., Rodrigues, L. L. & Desai, P. (2011). The role of top management in using knowledge management as a tool for innovation–a system dynamics perspective. In Proceedings of the World Congress on Engineering, London (Vol. 1).

Kazemi, M. & Zafar Allahyari, M. (2010). Defining a knowledge management conceptual model by using MADM. Journal of Knowledge Management, 14(6): 872-890.

Kerlinger, F.N. (1986). Foundations of Behavioral Research. Orlando: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.

Khatibian, N., Hasan Gholoipour, T. & Abedi Jafari, H. (2010). Measurement of knowledge management maturity level with in organizations. Business strategy series,11(1): 1751-5637.

King, W. R. (2008). Questioning the conventional wisdom: culture-knowledge management elationships. Journal of Knowledge Management, 12(3): 35-47.

KPMG Consulting (2000). Knowledge management research report. Available in:

Kruger, C. N. & Johnson, R. D. (2010). Information management as an enabler of knowledge management maturity: A South African perspective. International journal of information management, 30(1): 57-67.

Kundel, H. & Polansky, M. (2003). Measurement of observer agreement. Radiology  228: 303-308.

Kuriakose, K. K., Raj, B., Satya Murty, S. A. V. & Swaminathan, P. (2011). Knowledge management maturity model: an engineering approach. Journal of Knowledge Management Practice, 12(2): 1-17.

Lee, H. & Choi, B. (2003). Knowledge management enablers, processes, and organizational performance: An integrative view and empirical examination. Journal of management information systems, 20(1): 179-228.

Lee, J. & Kim, Y. (2001). A stage model of organizational knowledge management: A latent content analysis. Expert Systems with Application, 20(4): 299–311.

Liebowitz, J. & Wright, K. (1999). Does measuring knowledge make “cents”? Expert systems with applications, 17(2): 99-103.

Lin, C., Wu, J. C. & Yen, D. C. (2012). Exploring barriers to knowledge flow at different knowledge management maturity stages. Information & Management, 49(1): 10-23.

 Lin, H.F. (2011). Antecedents of the stage-based knowledge management evolution. Journal of Knowledge Management, 15(1): 136-155.

Lotti Oliva, F. (2014). Knowledge management barriers, practices and maturity model. Journal of Knowledge Management, 18(6): 1053-1074.

Malhotra, Y. (2001). Expert systems for knowledge management: crossing the chasm between information processing and sense making. Expert Systems with Applications, 20(1): 7-16.

Malhotra, Y. (2004). Why knowledge management systems fail: enablers and constraints of knowledge management in human enterprises. In Handbook on Knowledge Management 1 (pp. 577-599). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

Manian, A., Moosakhani, M., Hassanzadeh, A. & Jami Pour, M. (2014). Designing a Maturity Model of KM Aligned with Business Strategies Using Meta Synthesis Method. Journal of Information Technology Management. 6(2): 307-332. (in Persian)

Marr, B., Gupta, O., Pike, S. & Roos, G. (2003). Intellectual capital and knowledge management effectiveness. Management Decision, 41(8): 771-781.

Martinez, M. N. (1998). The collective power of employee knowledge. HR magazine, 43: 88-94.

Mathew, A. O., Rodrigues, L. L. & Vittaleswar, A. (2012). Human Factors & Knowledge Management: A System Dynamics Based Analysis. Journal of Knowledge Management Practice, 13(2). Available in: http://www.

Mehta, N., Oswald, S. & Mehta, A. (2007). Infosys Technologies: improving organizational knowledge flows. Journal of Information Technology, 22(4): 456-464.

Migdadi, M. (2009). Knowledge management enablers and outcomes in small and medium sized enterprises. Industrial management and data system, 109(6): 840-858.

Mohaghar, A., Mirkazemi-Mood, M. & Rahmany Youshanlouei, H. (2012). Modeling Relationship between R&D Activities and Organization Knowledge Stock Using System Dynamics Approach. Journal of Information Processing and Management, 28 (1):149-179. (in Persian)

Moffett, S., McAdam, R., & Parkinson, S. (2003). An empirical analysis of knowledge management applications. Journal of knowledge Management, 7(3): 6-26.

Monavarian, A., Moosakhani, M., Akhavan, P. & Asgarai, N. (2012). A model of human and social infrastructure enabler of Knowledge management practices Journal of Information Technology Management. 4(10):158-178. (in Persian)

Moriwaki, N., Nomura, K. I. & Senoo, D. (2013). A behavior-based approach for analyzing knowledge-process dynamics. Journal of service science and management, 6(2): 160-169.

Morgan, D. L., & Krueger, R. A. (1998). Planning focus groups (Vol. 2). Sage.

Oltra, V. (2005). Knowledge management effectiveness factors: the role of HRM. Journal of Knowledge Management, 9(4): 70-86.

Pee, L. G. & Kankanhalli, A. (2009). A model of organisational knowledge management maturity based on people, process, and technology. Journal of Information & Knowledge Management,8(02): 79-99.

Rai, R. K. (2011). Knowledge management and organizational culture: a the oretical integrative framework. Journal of Knowledge Management, 15(5): 779-801.

Rodrigues, L. L. & Martis, M. S. (2004). System dynamics of human resource and knowledge management in engineering education. Journal of Knowledge Management Practice, Available in: http://www.tlainc. com/articl77.htm.

Ruggles, R. (1998). The state of the notion: knowledge management in practice. California management review, 40(3): 80-89.

Sandelowski, M. & Barroso, J. (2007). Handbook for synthesizing qualitative research. Springer Publishing Company.

Sepehi Khameneh, F (2016). An Analysis of the Dynamics of Organizational Knowledge Management Maturity with an Emphasis on Human Factors and Organizational Culture, Master thesis, Tabriz University

Serenko, A., Bontis, N. & Hull, E. (2015). An application of the knowledge management maturity model: the case of credit unions. Knowledge Management Research & Practice.  DOI: 10.1057/kmrp.2014.37.

Singh Sandhawalia, B. & Dalcher, D. (2011). Developing knowledge management capabilities: a structured approach. Journal of Knowledge Management, 15(2): 313-328.

Skyrme, D. & Amidon, D. (1997). The knowledge agenda. Journal of knowledge management, 1(1): 27-37.

Soliman, F. & Spooner, K. (2000). Strategies for implementing knowledge management: role of human resources management. Journal of knowledge management, 4(4): 337-345.

Soliman, F. & Spooner, K. (2000). Strategies for implementing knowledge management: role of human resources management. Journal of knowledge management, 4(4): 337-345.

Teah, H.Y., Pee, L.G. & Kankanhalli, A. (2006). Development and application of a general knowledge management maturity model. Proceedings of the 10 th Pacific Asia Conference on Information Systems, pp. 401-416.

Tobin, T. (2003). Ten principles for knowledge management success. Gartner Inc., Stamford, CT.

Ulrich, D. (1998). Intellectual capital, competence and commitment. MIT Sloan Management Review, 39(2): 15-26.

Verespej, M. (1999). Knowledge management: system or culture? Industry Week, 248(15): 20-23.

Walsh, D. & Downe, S. (2005). Meta synthesis method for qualitative research: a literature review. Journal of advanced nursing, 50(2): 204-211.

Wang, D., Su, Z. & Yang, D. (2011). Organizational culture and knowledge creation capability. Journal of Knowledge Management, 15(3): 363-373.

Wickramasinghe, N., Bali, R. K. & Geisler, E. (2007). The major barriers and facilitators for the adoption and implementation of knowledge management in healthcare operations. International journal of electronic healthcare, 3(3): 367-381.

Wong, K. Y. & Aspinwall, E. (2003, September). Is knowledge management equivalent to information technology. In Proceedings of the Fourth European Conference on Knowledge Management, Oxford University, Oxford (pp. 989-97).

Wong, K. & Aspinwall, E. (2005). An empirical study of the important factors for knowledge-management adoption in the SME sector. Journal of Knowledge management, 9(3): 64-82.

Yahya, S. & Goh, W. K. (2002). Managing human resources toward achieving knowledge management. Journal of knowledge management, 6(5): 457-468.

Yazdani, H., Hamidizadeh, A. & Kameli, A. (2014). The effect of leadership style and organizational climate on knowledge management and organizational structure and the role of social interaction (Survey on the bank's staff). Journal of Information Technology Management. 7(1): 199-216. (in Persian)

Yeh, Y. J., Lai, S. Q., & Ho, C. T. (2006). Knowledge management enablers: a case study. Industrial Management & Data Systems, 106(6): 793-810.

Zimmer, L. (2006). Qualitative meta-synthesis: a question of dialoguing with texts. Journal of advanced nursing, 53(3): 311-318.